Did you ever have a relationship with someone who had really pronounced personality traits…and those traits happened to be what you most admired in them AND what would most drive you crazy about them?
Some examples:
We’ve all had these experiences. When the net benefits outweigh the contradictions, the relationship continues. And yet there is always that line that can be crossed where an inherent strength can become an annoyance.
Think of this in terms of your professional life. There are many initial reasons we got into education. And yet how many of those reasons have become a source of frustration for us at times over the years? Again, some examples:
|
Benefit |
Frustration |
|
Working with children
|
Changing expectations
|
|
Lifelong learning
|
Required professional development
|
|
Job security
|
Locked into pay scales
|
|
Professional stature
|
Media criticism
|
|
Making a difference
|
Being tied into accountability
|
|
Serving your community
|
Being treated as public employees
|
Those of us who truly see the value of being an educator, even in the face of the frustrations, continue to serve in education in different capacities as our careers continue to evolve. We are committed to our work, understanding the pros and cons. Others of us see the frustrations and leave the profession under their mounting weight. Then there are those of us who choose to stay in the profession even though we are frustrated for reasons of self-interest: salary, benefits, retirement.
Is that OK? It depends on who you ask. Certainly as professionals we are aware of our own interests as well as the interests of the greater good. We’re not philanthropists functioning in a vacuum. Still, how long do you stay in a relationship where you’re getting less and less out of it? And when you see other people together in an unhappy relationship, do they look like they’re doing one another a favor? It affects everyone around them.
We all know someone who is still working their job, collecting their paycheck, and not doing anyone any favors. They can be bitter, frustrated, burnt out…and they give us a bad name as a profession. Yet they don’t see the obligation they have to the children, their colleagues and the profession to move on to new work. I am not writing to suggest when or how this decision should be made; it’s a very personal self-assessment-and-decision-making process. But I am saying if you are still in the profession, and you no longer see the net benefits outweighing your frustrations, do a self-check and be aware of how this is affecting you. If you can take a good hard look at yourself and you still see that spark of idealism, that love of children and learning, that drive to make the world a better place, then you are in good stead. But if you realize your words and actions and attitudes impair your ability to be the educator you could and should be, maybe it’s time to ask yourself what you’d like to be doing the next 20 to 30 years. After all, no one wants to spend their life feeling stuck and frustrated.
Still not convinced? Well look at it from a point of self-interest...you owe it to yourself to do a gut check, whatever you decide...and in hindsight, you'll be glad you did.
Mirror site: http://surfaquarium.blogspot.com/
Walter’s blog archive: http://surfaquarium.com/blog.htm
Walter_McKenzie, 9 months ago | FlagGeorge you're an educator after my own heart! True life-long learners follow man paths, and often away from their original calling. Given that our students will have multiple careers in their lifetimes,how fitting that their teachers too follow their bliss!
George_Tucker, 9 months ago | FlagThanks Walter for sharing your thoughtful perspective. I have been very blessed to have enjoyed a career as an educator for the last 32 years. During that time, I have changed jobs nine different times. Each time the role change helped to challenge as well as invigorate me. For me, change is vital. Feeling challenged, valued and having an opportunity to make a valuable contribution is paramount to my job satisfaction. During the last 27 years I have been blessed to have an opportunity to work in leadership roles. During that time, I have often taken stock of my personal job situation and encouraged others to do the same. As you say, "You owe it to yourself". Life is certainly too short to be doing something that does not bring us satisfaction. From time to time, a colleague has left education. Sometimes, other colleagues will see the departure as negative. I personally applaude the move and congratulate the individual for having the courage to begin a new career that will hopefully provide the individual with job satisfaction. The last thing we need as a public and as educators are teachers who hate their jobs and are disengaged. Our students deserve better! So, thank you for framing the issue so nicely. Let's hope that your blog helps many educators to reflect on their personal job situations. If deemed necessary, let's hope that folks will change careers. Let's hope that they are able to achieve what Mark Twain put so well, "Find a job you truly love & you'll never work again". Wouldn't that be great? Cheers.
Walter_McKenzie, 9 months ago | FlagJulie thank you for your thoughtfulresponse. Yes over the years we have both kept moving on to keep ourselves engaged. Nothing is appetizing once it goes stale! :)
Juliette_Mersiowsky, 9 months ago | FlagWalter, as always, your writing makes me think way deeper than I normally do about topics that I wouldn't always think about. Thank you!
One of my favorite things about being a career educator is that when I found I was becoming disenchant
ed or too frustrated with some of those very things you listed in the frustratio ns/benefit s chart above, I am able to reinvent my educator self to enter a new place, a new position or even a totally new avenue of education. If you had asked me 20+ years ago what I would be doing in 2012, it sure wouldn't be where I am now. I am thankful I have had the ability to move around and to change hats when needed so that I can remain effective and still go home at the end of the day tired, but with a smile on my face. Thank you for reminding us that we all need to do a little profession
al soul searching everynow and then. Consider my gut checked!
Walter_McKenzie, 10 months ago | FlagMary thank you for speaking from your first-handexperience . We lose track of how much we impact each other with our actions and attitudes. We need each other to affirm the good we are doing and the difference we are making...w e're all in this together!
Flagging notifies the ASCD EDge webmaster of inappropriate content. Please flag any messages that violate the Terms of Service. Please include a short explanation why you're flagging this message. Thank you!
If you believe this content violates the Terms of Service, please write a short description why. Thank you.
Flagging notifies the ASCD EDge webmaster of inappropriate content. Please flag any messages that violate the Terms of Service. Please include a short explanation why you're flagging this message. Thank you!
Your First Name (optional)
Email Addresses (comma separated)
Import friends
Message to Friends (optional)
Are you human?
Or, you can forward this blog with your own email application.